Random Reading Reflections

feeling: thoughtful
I took a few hours out of my life today to read a book called Let it Snow, a collection of three Christmas stories (it says "holiday" on the cover but it's more or less Christmas) by prominent teen authors.
...Guys, I think I hate prominent teen authors. Reading three shorter stories more or less back-to-back helped to cement the fact that yes, pretty much every modern-day non-fantasy teen novel is exactly the same. And not in a good way! It seems to me that all of the books that fall into the above category are about an average teen (with a few quirks!) that has a series of crazy, but possible, events happen to him or her. There are several reasons why I generally don't like this form.
First, I really don't think that using "normal" as a base for your character is ever a good idea. "Normal - math skills + loves bacon + talks a lot" might work for a side character with a few lines, but it makes for a very dull lead. I realize that authors will want to create relateable characters, and they feel that making them normal with a few quirks is the best way of doing so. Unfortunately, everybody is normal with a few quirks, so the result is more "oh, hey, I like bacon too," than "oooh, I totally agree! Yeah, that's so true!". The thing is, a character isn't relateable because of personality traits, they are because of situations and emotions. Sure, I like to see an occasional character be a yaoi fangirl and whatnot, but that's not the important thing. In the end, I really don't care if Addie is pretty average except she's a bit self-centered and when she fights with her boyfriend she dyes her hair pink; I do care that Mitsuru is well-breed, has high expectations for both herself and others, and bears a lot of responsibility. "Normal" is almost meaningless now; use words with meaning.
As for the series of crazy but possible events thing, that just tends to go overboard. I like to see authors not try to make a whole book based on one gimmick, but there are limits in the other direction as well. When your heroine's parents are sent to jail, she's sent to meet up with them, her train breaks down, she leaves and goes to Waffle House, she leaves from there with a stranger to escape cheerleaders, they fall into a frozen pond, she bonds with his mom, breaks up with her boyfriend, and falls madly in love with the guy she just met -- all in 117 pages? (Actual story, seriously.) Too much is happening, and too much of it is bizarre.
And this is more of a pet peeve, but I don't think I've ever read a piece of modern-setting teen fiction that wasn't obviously written by an adult trying to sound like a teenager. It just... doesn't work. Heck, I follow John Green -- one the book's authors -- on Youtube and he absolutely writes like he talks. That doesn't matter, apparently, because he still writes like he's trying too hard to be cool (in his own nerdy little way) and relate to teens, and failing miserably.
Thus are the reasons that I pretty much stick to juvenile and adult fiction.












